I am building a new HO layout and will be using Atlas Code 83 track, but I am not sure which switch company I should use for my new layout. I am looking at Atlas and Peco, but would welcome any advice and any past experience that you may have with any of the switch manufacturers. Thanks, Michael
For the money, the Atlas turnouts will serve you well! There are others that are more realistic, but you will pay for that. IMHO, a little weathering on Atlas trackage goes a long way!
Mobilman44
Like you I am using Atlas code 83 flex track on my layout. I chose the Walthers code 83 turnouts made by Shinohara since the have the most realistic appearance, offer many different sizes, including curved turnouts and are quite reliable. But as the previous poster says the Atlas turnouts are virtually bullet proof. And if you paint and weather the rail they don’t look to bad. You won’t go wrong with either one.
Good luck!
I use mostly Shinohara and the work faily well. The truth is none of them work perfectly and will need to be adjusted if you use many different locomotives. From Atlas to Handlaid, turnouts are an artform that can be learned.
I am also using Walthers/Shinohara turnouts, but with Micro Engineering flex track. One thing I’ve noticed though, is that the Walthers code 83 rail joiners are ‘sloppy’ loose when trying to connect the ME track to the turnout. Anyone know why?
Even though both the turnouts and the flex track are code 83 their cross sections are different.
If you are sure you want to use Atlas Code 83 then you would probably be better off using Atlas 83 switches. A better recommendation, however, would be to go with Walthers/Shinohara track and switches. An even better recommendation would be to save dinero and go with Micro Engineering track and learn how to build and lay you own switches.
I am in nscale but have been very happy with Peco switches. They have a snap on them that keeps the points in contact. I have not used Atlas switches so cant judge them but have read lots of problems with poor connection with the points. This problem can be solved with a switch machine or Caboose Industry manual throw. I might also suggest that if you are using short wheel base engines and/or/sound engines you should use a switch with a live frog like Peco Electro-frog. I started using Peco Insul-frog (plastic frog) and had trouble with short engines/sound engine stalling on the frog. Maybe HO doesnt have that problem.