Ballast adhesive - yes or no?

What’s your opinion?

I’ve been research types of adhesives but haven’t stumbled upon any discussion of whether or not to even use it. I would greatly appreciate some discussion on the topic.

Tom

YOU MIGHT OF MISSED THIS ONE?

http://cs.trains.com/TRCCS/forums/t/159524.aspx

Sean

Hi, Sean.

I’ve been reading that thread quite carefully. My question is not so much what type as it is whether or not a ballast adhesive is needed.

In my case, I experimented today with some TiteBond III. I use pea gravel for ballast as my wife and I both prefer the variations in color that are provided. I mixed some TB III at 50/50 water/glue and another batch at 25/75 water/glue. The 25/75 held much better but I’m going to need a tanker full of the stuff to glue the ballast down.

In some places, yes I will need adhesive on some slopes. What I’m thinking about doing is gluing the ballast only on the slopes and leave the flat sections of track unglued, re-ballasting as necessary.

Tom

I am doing the same just using portland cement on the sides that need to be held in place.

BUT PEE gravel…vary hard to keep in place, to round, no sharpness to the stones to hold together.

Good luck!

Sean

Really depends on your weather, I live in San Diego, no need for anything holding ballast in place, I have good drainage, i.e. do not drain through the track from one side to another.

Regards, Greg