DCC Consist Composition

I am experimenting with DCC using a NCE Power Cab trying to learn the finer points. Yesterday I put together some odd consists to see how they would go. I am wondering if those of you who have lots of experience use any rules on what you will lash up.

One I was experimenting with was a 4-8-4+4-8-4 articulated loco double heading with a diesel. The steam loco has a QSI factory fitted decoder. On the Power Cab the version came up as 7. The diesel has a NCE D13SRJ as a temporary decoder while I am waiting for its ESU Loksound V3.5.

What I noticed was that the diesel was running a bit faster than the steam engine, so in one direction it was pushing on the coupling and the other way trying to pull away. Moreover the momentum seems to work better with the NCE decoder than the QSI, so the diesel was spinning wheels while running out its momentum pushing against the stopped steamer’s weight.[:O]

Obviously these two locos were not matched. I could do some adjusting to get them to run at about the same speed, but had not done that yesterday. Actually the diesel would pull top passenger expresses at times and has a fair top speed in the real world, but the steamer is freight only (except in dire emergencies). So I would not want to permanently slow down the diesel too much.

So what are you DCC experienced guys game to run as a consist?[?] For example, will you run only engines with the same model decoders? Do you run only pairs of the same engine? Do you ever mix steam and diesel?

PS. I know the lash up was not common prototypically. However, at times diesel and steam did run together as consists. I read somewhere that the diesel should lead because otherwise too much cinders got into the cooling fans. So put the prototypical argument aside and just deal with the DCC questions.

I’ve got 2 P2K GP-9’s, and 2 old Athearn F-7’s, all Milwaukee. One of each pair has a Digitrax decoder, and the other has a TCS decoder. I’ve found that I have to put the TCS engines in the consist in the Forward direction, because that decoder insists on doing this, regardless of how I set it up. The Digitrax decoders will go into the consist in Reverse, so it’s just one of those things I have to live with.

I think you can mess around with the variables in the decoder to get them to work better together. I know we had to this with some of our locos to get them to consist in a more prototypical fashion

hope this helps!

And my little brother and I don’t worry about prototypicalness either. For example we had a F7 A-B-B and a ACC400w(ithink) and an atlas vo1000 pulling the bulk of our rolling stock around our helix, so definetly not prototypical [;)]

You may try turning the EMF off. I do this to keep the engines from fighting each other, especially on grades. I can run anything I’ve got in any combination so far. My decoders are mainly Digitrax, NCE and Soundtrax. I have one TCS decoder that continually seems to lose control and make the loco run wide open. I’ve tried in several different brands of engines with the same effect. I have to reprogram it to get it to work right again. I guees this I what I get for $11.99 on-line! I finally gave up on it, so its in the scrap pile with another cheap decoder from MRC. I think I’ve learned my leason as I now stick to Digitrax and NCE. Tweet.