Dentist Wants to Start Montana Short Line

Dentist wants to run Montana shortline

(Gannett News Service circulated the following article by Brian Tumulty on November 1.)

WASHINGTON – The unused railroad line between Great Falls and Helena would reopen as an independent short line to foster competition in freight rail under an application filed with the federal Surface Transportation Board.

Dr. Daniel Fiehrer, a dentist from Helena, is asking the federal agency to award him “running rights” and let him purchase the 92-mile stretch of railroad from the BNSF Railway Co.based in Fort Worth, Texas.

Fiehrer is not the only one to express interest in the line.

The Helena-based Corridor of Discovery Action Committee has expressed interest in converting the line to a bicycle trail.

Trails advocates in Great Falls and Helena are urging development of the trail.

Both Cascade and Lewis and Clark counties and Great Falls and Helena city commissions have proclaimed their support for the trail.

Landowners along the corridor have reservations about the trail.

Standard concerns are trespass from the trail right of way onto private property, litter, dogs, fires, illegal camping and weed control.

Fiehrer, in a telephone interview Tuesday, said he wants to run one freight train daily on the single-track feeder line.

“We’re basically going to provide competition from central Montana to outside sources,” he said, explaining that it would provide a link to the Canadian Pacific, the Union Pacific and the Montana Rail Link. “It’s one of the few north-south routes from Canada to Mexico.”

Fiehrer said he doesn’t know how much the shipping cost of grain would change, but said he was confident prices would drop if there is competition.

Secondarily, the scenic 92-mile stretch along the Missouri River would be used for a dinner line, according to Fiehrer, who also is considering rail service for trout fishi

What does he propose to use for money? He talks like buying 92 miles of railroad and repairing a washout is no big deal.

I agree. Maybe the dentist needs to “drill down” to those details!

I strongly suspect that the dentist is a front man.

LC

I didn’t know dentists made that kind of dough!

For who? Another railroad? A politician’s re-election campaign? Shippers? I’m just curious.

Are you kidding? Have you paid a dentist bill lately? Billings last week probably covers the washout! lol

I have a former brother in law who is a dentist and believe me, they do make that kind of money, and more. I guess if you have to stick your hands in people’s mouths all day you want to be properly compensated and it passes through to the patient…

LC

Given that the article mentions that there are several interested short lines, I doubt it is a railroad. I’m thinking perhaps Michael Sol…LOL…

In all seriousness, perhaps agricultural interests…

LC

Michael sol?!? [(-D] Actually, the first thing I thought of when I read the article was that I didn’t realize futuremodal was a dentist… Agricultural interests makes sense, as being behind it. However, I would think it to be mostly a tactic to force lower freight rates from whatever railroad they’re useing now (([;)])). Couldn’t BNSF simply say “Put up, or shut up. The price is $2.5 billion. Write us a check”? Or, is there some regulatory factors that determine what an owner can sell his property for?

Do you know the heritage of the line in question? I’m guessing? The article mentions the “north-south” route from Mexico to Canada. Would this line have friendly connections at each end?

The Milwaukee Road used to serve Great Falls, didn’t it?

Where would the traffic come from if BNSF owns everything from Great Falls and MRL is the only connection at Helena?

Those washouts are easy–a little water, a little air, and a little amalgam…

And paid for by a couple of root canals![:-,]

The first question that came to my mind was how does he plan to link to the CP and UP? The way I see it he can only do that via the BNSF out of Great Falls. I don’t recall reading about CP getting rights beyond Sweet Grass.

My next thought was where is he going to get the mty covered hoppers from?

Just the guy if you need a new tunnel…

LC

I was wondering about the interchanges myself, but I figured he knew something I didn’t. As for the cars, since cash does’nt seem to be a problem I guess they’ll go lease them…LOL…this is what happens when people who are frustrated by railroads get a hard lesson in the cold realities of running a railroad…

LC

Or replacing the washout with a bridge. (Groan)

I don’t know if we’ve gotten a good impression, but this could be his crowning achievement. But, as some people have suggested, it could be a bit of an overbite on his part.

The line in question is one I’ve refered to in the past as part of the I-15 rail corridor between SoCal and Alberta. CP, BN, and UP used to team up and run a potash unit train on this line back in the day. The line could be a very valuable piece of property if the parties in question could learn to cooperate - it’d take a lot of traffic off the congested I-5 rail corrid

Shouldn’t this one be under the “OPEN ACCESS” Thread?!?!
Seems like everyones got their mouths open about this one!!