Does anyone make metal frogs to replace Peco insulfrogs?

Model Railroader Electronics and DCC
1

I have a lot of Peco Insulfrog turnouts. I am wondering if anyone manufactures a replacement frog that is metal, so that it can be wired as a true, LIVE electrofrog?

I’ve seen DIY videos where people use aluminum foil or tape, or conductive paint, but these seem to be more of a band-aid than a real alteration. I’m looking to remove the plastic frog and replace it with something metal that can be wired appropriately. I know I could build something from scrap rail pieces, but looking to see if there is already something available before I try to re-create a wheel.

(My other option is to install keep alives on my locos, but that will defeat my “fail-safe dead-zones” on my lift out approaches!)

2

Welcome to the forums Chad!

I’m surprised to hear you are having issues with the frogs on Peco turnouts as they are so small. What locomotives are you having trouble with? I don’t know of anyone who makes a ready replacement for those frogs, but I would try eBay and maybe Etsy as starters.

3

Or if it’s within your budget just replace the entire turnout with an electro frog or unifrog.

Regards, Chris

4

Micro Engineering sells switch kits points frogs etc. Maybe they would sell you some frogs. It doesn’t hurt to ask.

5

Details West makes cast manganese frogs in code 55, 70 and 83 in HO scale; their website has a catalog with many options. Whether any of those frogs are currently in stock is a good question. It might be worth a call or an email to Details West to see if the frogs are available, and where you can order/buy them from.

6

Precision Scale Products used to sell cast frogs.

7

What locomotives do you have problems with?

My previous layout (and the new one I am currently building) have around 120 Peco Insulfrog turnouts and I don’t have any issues with locomotives stalling.

Maybe it’s a problem with your locomotives/wiring?

8

The March Railroad Model Craftsman has a nice article about Peco turnouts and locomotive wheel issues. Boils down to the taper or lack of it on the wheel. Also includes a fix to get around the problem. I’ve found all Peco products to be highly reliable.
Mark B.