[quote user=“Miningman”]
You can’t fool an old horsefly! It’s humbug I tell ya, humbug[/I quote]
See the correspondence preserved at the Hagley about putting the still-beloved Big Engine in the Northumberland collection. That was about the closest we got. The Ts and Qs had a long and expensive paying-for before one could be preserved. I assume you know that Westinghouse took its turbine back and the rest of the S2 at that point was perhaps best forgotten by PRR.
I won’t go into Perlman and Young over on NYC except to note that yes, it was a preservation shame. And the list of ‘we came so close’ including the EM-1, the Reading Pacific, and all those 4-6-4s for the Louisiana and Eastern is so long.
But it’s also true that much of the cash-strapped Northeastern railroads with the most interesting power needed or wanted the scrap value more than the goodwill from obsolete history … we have different priorities now, but it’s only fair to consider what railroad eyes saw then.