What a fascinating subject for discussion! Now retired from decades as a professional in the field of history, I’ve learned a thing or two about how history can be written, and rewritten and rewritten and rewritten ad infinitum.
That served me well when I decided decades ago, to build a freelance pike whose story might seem well grounded in plausible history. Or at least, up to a point. It’s not like I’m writing my railroad’s history for peer-reviewed publication, after all.
My railroad is the Great Lakes & Hudson’s River RR [GLHR]. It got that name because I wanted to say something about the points of origin of myself and my spouse. That’s really all I needed, to begin building a railroad and a story to go with it. It doesn’t need to mean anything to anyone but me. But that last sentence is loaded with wiggle room.
As my idea for the Great Lakes grew, so did a couple of other things. My knowledge of American railroad history served as a foundation, allowing me to do what literally every Class I railroad did, picking up pieces of previously existing railroads along my way (literally) from New York City to Petoskey, MI. In my backstory, I amalgamated the Erie and the DLW decades before anyone else did. But I kept their reporting marks on some rolling stock, as divisions of the GLHR. To me, it just adds interest, and doing that is perfectly plausible as historic railroads did that right and left. GLHR also snapped up the Pere Marquette before the C&O got its hands on it. It operates as another GLHR division, and gives me a reason to add “Pere Marquette Railway” to the top of some steam loco tenders while they carry GLHR reporting marks and numbering. There are a number of freight cars where you can still read the faded PM marks under the GLHR patches, as is also the case with a few former DLW and Erie cars. A few of them are still awaiting new paint jobs too.
I’m competing with giants like the NYC and PRR, so its logical and plausible that they make occasional appearances near my GLHR, including, without reference to plausibility, at the massive Union Station that serves as GLHR’s HQ building.
The fact is, that while we sometimes think of our historic railroads as having had an orderly existence, they were always all a mess, as they remain today, reminding some of us of a seething ball of worms. There’s no reason to think our own railroads can’t or shouldn’t reflect that turbulent history and evolution in the way we build our pikes and mark our engines and other rolling stock. It’s kind of okay, to explain something with a convoluted history with some of the convolutions quite apparent. Goodness knows that is a historical accuracy of nationwide proportions!