High Speed Rail Line to Link Calgary & Edmonton

From yesterdays Calgary Herald.

A Calgary company is proposing to link Alberta’s two major cities by high-speed rail as part of a joint project with the province, aimed at easing congestion on one of Canada’s busiest travel corridors.

The plan would see the government spend an estimated $1.6 billion to buy the land & build a 300 kilometer passenger line between Calgary & Edmonton. All other expenses - including buying trains & selling tickets - would then be handed off to Alberta High-Speed Rail Inc., a private firm backed by Western Canadian investors.

“Our solution is the Crown would own the land on which the rail was built,” said president BIll Cruickshanks, “We are offering to share the public sector risk. Trains would be owned & operated the same as an airline or a bus company by a private firm without any government subsidy or support.”

The travel time between Calgary’s downtown & Edmonton by high-speed train would be 84 minutes, according to AHSR’s research. That’s twice as fast a vehicle or even an airplane, Cruickshanks notes.

The company is proposing hourly departures between the 2 cities - once every half hour during peak commuting times - & a coach fare of $65 one way. Some 3000 passengers would be expected to use service every day.

“Our project is justifiable to the public,” said Cruickshanks, “All over Europe, they’ve built thousands of kilometers of high-speed. If you can move people from point A to point B quickly, efficiently & at a good price, it will be used.”

The concept of a high speed rail link between the provinces two largest cities has been discussed since the 1970’s but often dismissed.

Premier Ralph Klein has indicated he doesn’t approve of taxpayers footing the bill of what could potentially be a white elephant.

But a 2004 report from the Van Horne Institute, a transportation think-tank, argues there are enough would be travellers & economic benefits to warrant the route

“The ridership would be sufficient for the service to break even from day one said Peter Wallis, chairman of the Van Horne Institute.”

Yea, OK, good luck with that one.

Ho hum, another newspaper article about the high-speed rail to Edmonton, this rears it’s head about every 5 years, and in a week, not one more word on it. This fantasy has been going around since 1960(or earlier) when the C&E actually existed and you could take a train to both cities, but I would not go down to the train station in Calgary with your suitcase and wait to be whisked away to Edmonton in 84 minutes any time soon. Can you imagine the cost of a project like this??? land acquisition, crossings, bridges, stations, train equipment(which will be made in China) and on and on, all for a great big province with trillions of dollars and very few people. And 3000 people every day would use the service?? why would 3000 people travel from one city to another? Just how many people travel back and forth now? you can be assured it’s not anywhere 3000. That would mean the entire population of each city would each travel,once a year to the other city, hardly likely. This is just another news filler for the newspaper, and let me know in 3 months just how construction is coming along.

This is why I posted this article from the Herald. It shows how office bureaucrats sitting in an ivory tower can make up statistics to show how well their projects will work. The [:o)]. I think any statistics are just made up on the spot or pulled out of a hat to try to justify some make work project for white collar workers. Who ever believes puts blind faith in statistics is behind the [8].

I would take it…but I really do doubt the numbers. I just can’t imagine it being profitable, even without the initial investment of billions of [oil] dollars. We should spend our [oil] dollars on schools and healthcare instead of this idea. It’s a long way between Calgary and Edmonton…Even though I would love it if it existed. (as in “W00t, finally rail service is back after 15 years!”)