NYC commuter cars,hudson div. 1950s?

In HO,which model(s) would be “right” for the nyc commuter cars ?

The “Workshop” column in the April 2005 issue of MR had an article on converting one of the Branchline Trains heavyweight coaches into a pretty convincing model of the coaches that NYC used on commuter trains. I grew up near the West Shore line in northern New Jersey and remember the commuter trains before they were taken off in 1959…the model looked good to me.