Roll bars on Box Cars and Icicles

As I lived on the bluffs of the Bow River Valley high above the mainline of the CP railroad where it heads up the valley towards the Rockies, naturally I keep binoculars ready near the west facing windows. I enjoy the routine freight traffic, the meat and potatoes of CP, but the oddities that I spot on the rails are the true gravy.

Some summers I spot MOW crews with long black grimy units grinding and polishing the rails with sparks flying creating a noise that even a mile away is frightening. These rail grinders are followed by rail-riding pickup trucks with water tanks hosing –down the small fires lit by the sparks in the dry vegetation. This could make an interesting scene to model.

Once per season the CP hauls out a steam locomotive for a passenger consist to Banff. If it is a crisp cool autumn morning with the aspens turning yellow its distinctive sound penetrates your skin and the steam fills the valley lingering long after the train has past, like a memory. This is the season I am thinking of scenicing on my small fictitious CP subdivision modeled in a narrow Front Range valley of the Rockies.

April, some literary-types say, is the cruelest month—up here winter is not finished yet. This time of year we are into the fight between winter and spring. My question involves an oddity that I have spotted in and amongst the routine freights. It is a box car with a frame constructed of yellow I beams shaped like a large roll bar built on top the box. Sometimes there are two traveling together. What are they?

My reasoning suggests that it is some contraption that is intended to knock the icicles off the tunnels, portals and bridge overpasses. Ordinarily I do not see these cars in the dead of winter but usually in early spring and I suppose this is because they are kept up in the mountains or because the spring thaw is icicle season.

Are these boxcars with roll bars for tunnel clearance? Has anyone modeled icicles on their model RR? If

The structures on top of the boxcars are as you suggested in your subject - roll bars. Some boxcars carry very heavy stuff and are prone to roll over, so these things protect them if they do.

Oops! April Fools Day is over! Nevermind.

In reality they are as you guessed - to remove icicles in tunnels. CP has used boxcars and hopper cars in the past. Way back when they had real passenger trains, some of the F units had icicle breakers on them too - simpler ones - to remove the possibility of the ice hitting the dome cars.

Bob Boudreau

Not so foolish after all, Southern Pacific for years equipped a variety of motive power with metal bar ice breakers just as you described. In the 70’s SP re-thought the ice breaker issue, there had been several cases of the bars ripping out whole sheets of ice from tunnels and snowsheds and impacting cab roofs, cartops and intruding through cab windows at great risk to the crew.

It was far more safer and cheaper to send a crew out to blast such ice invasion by the use of dynamite prior to permitting trains to enter such dangerous operating conditions.

An ice breaker boxcar seems plausible to me, but, you better ballast that sucker!!!

Dave

Remembering F units with the ice breakers for dome cars going west in Calgary, I just assumed all F units were equipped with them, they were offset and split, Any F unit without them looked really strange, I forgot all about them till now.

I believe this is what you saw. Cortesy Railpictures.net