Penny,
Just one correction/answer
Clue 1 William F. Hafner and William O. Coleman started manufacturing toy (wind-up) trains in Chicago in 1907 (not 1900 as your clue indicates).
I am still not sure what Clue 2 refers to? It appears to be a jumble of American Flyer history.
Could Clue 2 possibly be referring to Edmonds-Metzel MFG becoming American Flyer Manufacturing in 1910? Or is it referring to when William F. Coleman left American Flyer in 1914 to form Hafner (Overland Flyer) trains?
NWL
My resources suggested these variables:
- O’Brien’s Collecting Toy Trains 5th Edition, 1999 Krause Publications: "American Flyer began in 1900 when William Hafner of Chicago, Illinois went into business as a toy manufacturer. When wind-up trains were added to the line-up, William Coleman was brought in as a financial partner. By 1910, trains were the firm’s strongest line, and the company’s name was changed to American Flyer"
- Toy Trains of Yesteryear c. 1972, 1987 Carstens Publications, Inc. Collection of articles written by Case Kowal for Toy Trains Magazine during 1953 and 1954: “Although the American Flyer M<anufacturing Company was founded in 1907…” Article is primarily about the AF O gauge No. 3020 locomotive.
- The American Toy Train by Gerry & Janet Souter,MBI Publishing Company1999: Under the heading “Hafner Company Enters The Toy Train Market” in chapter 3: (Hafner) “put his mechanical energies into developing a wind-up motor that was both simple and reliable. In 1901, the young mechanic formed the Hafner Company and put his motor into toy trucks, tiny doll swings, and a sheet metal automobile…” And later in the entry: “Finally, in 1905, after seeing interest rising for toy trains, he put his wind-up motor into a cast-iron locomotive shell and never looked back.”
So, I have 3 sources all giving different dates.
Clue 2 is about a UP train name and a country, if that clears it up. It’s really all abo
[quote user=“Penny Trains”]
Nationwidelines
Clue 1 William F. Hafner and William O. Coleman started manufacturing toy (wind-up) trains in Chicago in 1907 (not 1900 as your clue indicates).
My resources suggested these variables:
- O’Brien’s Collecting Toy Trains 5th Edition, 1999 Krause Publications: "American Flyer began in 1900 when William Hafner of Chicago, Illinois went into business as a toy manufacturer. When wind-up trains were added to the line-up, William Coleman was brought in as a financial partner. By 1910, trains were the firm’s strongest line, and the company’s name was changed to American Flyer"
- Toy Trains of Yesteryear c. 1972, 1987 Carstens Publications, Inc. Collection of articles written by Case Kowal for Toy Trains Magazine during 1953 and 1954: “Although the American Flyer M<anufacturing Company was founded in 1907…” Article is primarily about the AF O gauge No. 3020 locomotive.
- The American Toy Train by Gerry & Janet Souter,MBI Publishing Company1999: Under the heading “Hafner Company Enters The Toy Train Market” in chapter 3: (Hafner) “put his mechanical energies into developing a wind-up motor that was both simple and reliable. In 1901, the young mechanic formed the Hafner Company and put his motor into toy trucks, tiny doll swings, and a sheet metal automobile…” And later in the entry: “Finally, in 1905, after seeing interest rising for toy trains, he put his wind-up motor into a cast-iron locomotive shell and never looked back.”
So, I have 3 sources all giving different dates.
All of this just proves how much we’ve learned in the last 20 years. Probably due to #1 CTT, #2 the internet and #3 better auction reporting in general whether web based or not.
As expected Clue number 2 is incorrect. Actually, Hafner’s Overland Flyer brand started in 1914 after he left American Flyer.
NWL