“Our long distance train network provides these benefits (list) that have monetized value of ($$). As you can see, that exceeds their cost to operate by ($$).”
You’d think they’d say this every time. If it were true…
Or, at least you’d think they would be working very hard to make it at least close to true.
Most of the participants in these forums appear to be older guys, I suspect, many of whom are retired, discussing trains. Doing so without taking into consideration the nation’s larger transportation network would make for a sterile discussion.
At the end of the day the people who make the decisions, i.e. executive management, government officials, etc. are not going to take our views on-board. That’s OK. It is still fun. Moreover, if one is willing to keep an open mind, he or she may have a view changed or at least consider doing so.
Some of the participants want to control what is said on these forums. That is not their role; it belongs to the moderators. I for one like a bit of ranging. It stimulates the discussions and the mind.