Reader Jim’s is most dramatic…So is Brian’s but Jim’s just a little more edgy…I’ve seen more dramatic photo’s over the years, but these two stand out here.
Ken Fitzgerald’s shot is classy, and it’s hard to resist a yellow UP streamliner with E-units, but Jim Ribar’s shot is the only one of the lot that made me say “Wow!” when I saw it full-size on my screen.
I voted for Ken Fitzgerald’s because you just can’t beat the color and the fact everything is in focus. You can do that with a high F stop. I liked all of them. Brian Schmidt’s held the closest to the concept of storm clouds since his day apparently was shut down with clouds after that.
We live in an amazing country of amazing beauty. The most feelings of homesickness come from the shots of trains in the midwest and midsouth and north central US. Rail photos almost always lead us to natural landscapes.
I felt that Jim’s looked like he had exaggerated the color saturation in post-processing, but the clouds were spectacular enough that I voted for it anyway.
…No contest. Jim Ribar was very fortunate to be at this location and at the correct timing…And was able use his skills to capture a dramatic, photo…The quality of light and how it has made possible this quality of photograph is outstanding in this “storm light” railroad photo.