Weathering The Roof Of The Atlas Train Station

I am not good with colours, that green roof that is on the Atlas train station is driving me nuts. Can someone tell me what colours to use on it and maybe post a pic I would be grateful. Paint or powders it doesn’t matter. I weathered most of it years ago, everything but the roof. I think it is supposed to be a moss coloured shake roof. I wished Atlas would have made it shake brown instead of that ugly green. Make it look new and we can take it from there.

It is one of those things on the layout I never got around to finishing even though a few minutes is all it will take. Now is the time!

Thanks.

First I would paint the roof a darker color like reefer gray, then dry brush it with a lighter gray to highlight the detail.

A weathered shake roof (probably cedar) would be a light-ish gray brown:

Tom

I’ve had some good results with the old stand-by, India ink wash.

A few of my structures are the Walthers “Built-ups” that have a factory finish (usually unpainted plastic). My intention is to re-finish these “someday”.

In the interim, I have given them the Indi ink treatment and it is a quick way to age the structure and make some of the details stand out.

In some cases I masked the windows and gave them a dusting of Dullcote, then did a light ink wash.

I much prefer kits, of course, but a few of these structures were only available as built-up at the time.

Good Luck, Ed

I’ve not seen green shakers, tho in humid Maryland if we had shaker roofs they might be green. Go brown with grey or all grey. I hear there are 50 shades

LOL

Any color but green.

I will second George’s recommendation of Reefer Gray.

Rich

Ah, but like all things, it depends: green shingles are incredibly common in some parts of the country. Slate roofs too (you know, like the same kind of material they used to make green chalkboards out of!). There were definitely B&O and PRR stations with green roofs out there.

I did not know that. If you don’t put your opinion out there, you don’t find out how little you know.

Aye…

RR_views_0039 by Edmund, on Flickr

Regards, Ed

I used Plastruct Styrene shingle sheets for a recent scratch built home. I’d never used Styrene shingles before. I did a Google search for weathering and several sites advised to use a light grey primer. Scratch up the singles with a steel wire “Distresser” then India Ink to bring out the wood grain.

http://hon3annual.com/turning-styrene-into-wood/

It worked pretty good.

Mel

Modeling the early to mid 1950s SP in HO scale since 1951

Yet, he seemed to make it clear that he did not prefer green.

Rich

Now I could live with that green. The green on my Atlas station looked like a bright neon green. I think I will go with a dark gray with an India ink wash.

It is funny how the brain of a slightly colour blind person works. If I say something is green and someone tells me its gray and I look at it again, I will see gray, go figure.[:|]

Thanks all.

Model a winter scene…paint it white or throw some flour or baking powder on it and call it fresh snow [:D]

It is next to a grain elevator, so how about lots of pigeon droppings.[:D]

Sorry…

I was simply reinforcing the statement that green roofs were somewhat common on some railroad structures.

I’ll keep my nose out of other people’s business in the future.

Ed

No problem, Ed.

I was just pointing out that Brent appeared to be looking for an alternative color to green, not whether green was an appropriate roof color.

It’s all Nittany Lion’s fault. [(-D]

Rich

Hey, Rich—

I was just looking for an excuse to post that old photo I’ve had laying around! I knew I remembered a green roof from somewhere and it wasn’t a Lucy Maud Montgomery book, either [:D]

Hopefully Brent will find a good way to tone-down or change that depot.

Cheers! Ed

Hey, Ed, truth be told, I really like that photo of the train station that you posted. Since Brent has revealed that he is somewhat color blind, maybe that green color on his station is not as ugly as he believes that it is. [X-)]

Rich

I painted mine light gray then weathered it with a darker gray and it turned out real well. Anything but green…

You may be on to something Rich. I know I am much younger and better looking than the guy I see in the mirror every morning.[(-D]