Hello Dr. D!
First off, my congratulations to your father for being a good shot!
Second, how did I latch on to a Rock-Ola carbine. Welllll, if you worked for a gun company and firearms importer as I did back in the 80’s it was easy! We’d imported a number of M-1 carbines from Isreal, former IDF weapons, and there was a whole conucopia of makes in the bunch, Winchester, Inland, Saginaw, IBM, Quality Hardware, Underwood, and Rock-Ola. I grabbed a Rock-Ola as I loved the irony of a juke box manufacturor making rifles, can’t get any further from juke boxes than that! A buddy of mine who was a professional data processor bought one of the IBM’s.
The “intact from the maker” versus “arsenal rebuild” controversy is one I’ve never concerned myself with. As an old Marine I can tell you that when a weapon goes to a repair depot the armorer doing the rebuild doesn’t care who’s parts he uses, all he cares about is when he’s done the thing has to WORK, because if it doesn’t some poor guy’s going to die, and he doesn’t want it to be his fault.
Personally, I don’t mind rebuilds because all that means to me is the rifle’s been where the action is and has a story to tell, as opposed to one that’s museum quality and hasn’t gone anywhere or done anything. Depends on your point of view I suppose. I’ve got an M-1 Garand that has a WW2 Springfield reciever, a Winchester trigger housing group, and a 1966 produced Springfield barrel but I don’t care, it shoots beautifully.
Don’t believe the old husbands tale of some carbines were better than others, they were all made to the same specs, and if the manufacturor couldn’t meet those specs, like the Pedersen company, they lost the contract.
Nothing crude about the Rock-Ola I’ve got, it’s first rate.
Lady Firestorm and I even got an M-1 carbine as a wedding present! It’s