Akane brass Ma & Pa 2-8-0 review

This review is on Akane’s HO scale brass Maryland And Pennsylvania 2-8-0 steam engine.[:D]

There isn’t much prototype information (mostly just specifications), so I’ll just give a link: http://www.steamlocomotive.com/consolidation/?page=mapa

The model, like a lot of earlier brass pieces, is completely hand-built using mostly very basic parts and materials. The construction is almost completely brass sheet, tube, and rod. The only cast parts I can find are the wheel centers and tender trucks, which are a more typical zinc alloy rather than brass. Although the detail is certainly not up to the standards of today or even 40 years ago, those few people in their little tool shop in Japan made a good looking and pretty accurate model! Many parts, such as the marker lights, are obviously oversized and incorrect, but the model overall looks pretty close to the few pictures I’ve found of the prototype. And if greater detail is ever wanted, most of the less accurate parts can be replaced fairly easily. The greatest discrepency is the complete lack of a firebox, which was left out to fit Akane’s open-frame motor. I’m sure a skilled person could make a firebox from scratch, but this would also require a complete repower of the model. The same goes for a cab interior, which is not present. The cast drive wheels are pre-painted in flat black with the brass rims left in plated nickel. The cast centers aren’t clean, but most of the flash is in the back and is not usually visible. The center drivers are correctly blind. The tender is well detailed and has fewer compromises than the engine, although there are still some inaccuracies. The reverse lig

While I will more than likely will never go Brass, good review Braden. I all wise look forward to them.

Ken

You never know! I didn’t think I’d ever be able to afford brass, but I’ve found some great deals at train shows! For example:

Westside/Samhongsa D-16sb 4-4-0 - $180
Tenshodo GP20 - $50
Alco/KMT C-630 - $95 (I think?)
Akane 2-8-0 - $160

That’s less than a few of my plastic and diecast models![:D]

Many of the '60s and early '70s brass steam engines were made with running in mind – the range of steam locomotives that looked like a specific prototype was pretty limited otherwise. Westside, LMB, and PFM are a couple of the names. Makers included Akane, Tenshodo and others. With the kind of tweaks the reviewer describes, they have a lot of miles in them. There was a much better selection then of smaller locomotives and logging engines.

Darth,Great review of a very nice locomotive.

For Your information…

There was another Ma & Pa 2-8-0.

I really liked this one but,never owned one

United Models MA & PA 2-8-0 #s 23-26.

The United steamers was IMHO the best of the best as they was very smooth runners.

http://hoseeker.org/pacificfastmailinformation/PFM9thcatalog1964pg04.jpg