Hello everyone!
How do the n scale GG1’s from hold up to each other? Specifically the Bachmann, Kato, and BLI GG1’s (or any others that currently make them)
I have a GG1 already, and I want to get a second. The one I have is Kato so I’m inclined to get another of the same brand, but since I run DCC they’re all about the same cost so I figure id ask around before I bought anything.
Thanks
Given the choice of anything in those three brand names, especially in N scale, I would get the Kato model without any second thought.
I had a massive fleet of Kato N scale locomotives, and never had a single problem with any of them.
About 1/3 or so of my HO diesel fleet has Kato drives, and again, zero problems.
-Kevin
I just like the way Kato’s are made, quality materials, no glue because everything interlocks together and at least everything I own has ran excellent from day one and they seem to last forever. Also if you ever do need parts, they can for the most part be found. They also seem to hold up well being handled a lot.
Ralph
Is there any review of the scale appearance, proportional accuracy, and detail?
my understanding was that BLI was better for fine detail, Kato generally ran better (but was still super detailed), and then that Bachmann was the mid-low range option, but occasionally made something really good like the EM-1, so I was curious how the polls came out for this specific model.
I have 5 Bachmann’s and 2 Katos, (plus a model power 4-6-2 and some junky 80’s engines). I’ve found that the Katos run amazing, but that the Bachmann’s vary hugely, I have the Bachmann 4-6-0 that runs pretty poorly, but then my Bachmann DCC/DC K4 runs really good. I was wondering if their GG1 might be one of the good ones… (and I have no experience with BLI but I’ve heard some very mixed things)
All newer Bachmann models are very good, I love mine.
Still, given any choice where Kato is an option, I would go there. Excellent performance and rock-solid reliability are selling points for me.
-Kevin
I also do N Scale, and I vote for Kato.
hmm, I kinda expected that Kato was going to be much better than Bachmann (not to mention that the drawbar capacity on the Kato is rather enticing for my helices), but I’m admittedly surprised that BLI isn’t even in the running…
Anyway, thanks for the info, looks like ill be ordering my second Kato GG1!
My only experience with BLI was in HO scale, and it was terrible.
-Kevin
I’m also in HO, and I’m happy with my BLI Hudson. I also like my Bachmann GG1.
Ok, I had to cement the worm gear to to the BLI drive shaft, and replace the non-Kadee couplers on the GG1, but these are pretty much things that go along with being a model railroader.
I saw one of the new HO scale Bachmann GG1s running at Dana’s Railroad supply in Spring Hill, Florida, and it was an excellent performer.
-Kevin
There is one real choice Kato due to the superior drive.