Commemorative & Fantasy Models (Presidents, Events, NMRA, Magazines, Clubs, LHSs, etc.)

This is another box car for which the 1:1 scale prototype exists.

Orchard Supply Hardware




Orchard Supply Hardware is a retail chain that deals in home gardening supplies. It operated mainly in California from 1931 to 2018. In the early 1960s, the second-generation president, Albert B. Smith, wanted to put up a large sign at the flagship store in San Jose, but the city hall refused permission. So he bought a box car from SP, painted green, and parked it on the siding behind the store. 50 years later, in 2013, the box car was donated to the California Trolley and Railroad Corporation and is on display at the Kelley Park Historic Area. Orchard Supply Hardware - Wikipedia

The history of the MDC model is unknown. It is estimated to have been released around 1976.

The chain is also known for using railroad-related paintings on its annual calendar. The cover of the 2017 edition featured the box car from the siding era by James Mann.

6 Likes

@BN7150, where do you get all of these models?

I want to join in lol!

2 Likes

@GabeTehGameh, thanks for watching.
I don’t have any special route to acquire these models. Like everyone else, I get them from LHS, swap meets and the internet. I’ve been collecting them steadily for over 30 years. Surprisingly, 20% of them were acquired in Japan. I also received some from friends who know my tastes. These models are not popular, so they were inexpensive. And in the past few years, there have been extremely few listings for models I want. Moreover, with the weak yen, my eyes pop out when they are listed with shipping included.

3 Likes

Muriel Cigars




Train-Miniature stock#2041 Tobacco Road Series

4 Likes

Lucky Strike Cigarettes




Train-Miniature stock#2216 Tobacco Road Series


Page 128 of the Oct. 1975 of RMC magazine

For a complete list of Train-Miniature products, see SteamLocomotive.com.

5 Likes

The tobacco boxcars remind old Japanese modelers of Kikuchi Fumio (1914-1989). He was a scratch builder active in the early days of HO scale. He contributed to a magazine for beginners, and influenced countless people.

The first issue of the new railway model magazine “Train” in 1975 devoted nine pages to introducing his work. Among the pages, most of which were brass, one particularly shining page was a group of tobacco freight cars (see photos). This was the only page in color. They were made from US and Japanese cigarette wrappers in the early 1950s. Yes, this was 20 years before the Train-Miniature series was released.



Because I grew up looking at such things, I don’t feel strange about fantasy models, and I even think I like them. For me, the model exists first, and the real thing is merely a motif.

His posthumous works are on display at the Shibaura Institute of Technology’s Toyosu Library.

5 Likes

Mail Pouch Tobacco




Tyco (brown box) stock#374A in 1979

Mail Pouch is a brand name of chewing tobacco. From 1890 to 1992, the walls of farm barns were used as advertising media, resulting in the creation of “barn ads” (Wikipedia). The structures are sold in HO scale by Alpine Division Scale Models (photo from Walthers site).

3 Likes

Westinghouse Electric



Interpreting factory numbers to date your Tyco train set - Model Railroader / General Discussion (Model Railroader) - Trains.com Forums


Image credit: Liveauctioneers

PS: Now, there are no listings for this model on eBay. Instead, CMR Products offers a wide variety of decals for Westinghouse cars. May 20, 2025

6 Likes

AmstedRail, ASF



One thing to note is that the model is equipped with roller bearing trucks. Are these ASF Ride Control Trucks? I don’t know how to tell them apart from Barber Stabilized Trucks.

4 Likes

Since my railroad is from a merger of the “Lionel Lines”, any one of the 5,000,000,000 Lionel commemorative cars actually fits in on my RR!

3 Likes

@Engine_19881, all of the Lionel commemorative cars are very colorful. Please show us your proud car.

UPS, United Parcel Service




Walthers 40’AAR modernized 1948 boxcar #102525 stock#910-1179 US$29.98 released in 2019?

4 Likes

You want to see them? They’re not really fancy…


I also have this Menards car that doesn’t fit into my RR’s operating scheme. :frowning:

Still, I rather like it anyway! :slight_smile:

7 Likes

Have you ever considered getting a Menards railcar and repainting it?

I’m going to start doing that soon :smiley:

2 Likes

I have considered such a project but haven’t done so. I may have too, seeing as they have a number of items that I want but in different paint schemes.

2 Likes

I thought about Kitbashing one of them as a Passenger car :rofl:

3 Likes

Never worked out though the Amfleet I body is a little too big

3 Likes

That’s something Menards really should make.

1 Like

Agreed!

It would be really nice too :thinking:

1 Like

Maybe I’ll beat them to it!

That would be interesting :thinking:

It would be though if they did make the Amfleet I