Went to a train show this weekend and viewed some bridge piers that were made from extruded foam and the stonework scribed in with a ballpoint pen. I have mentioned this in a couple of threads where folks were trying to make piers or stone walls.
The gentleman who gave the clinic a couple of years ago was there and I asked if the piers on the layout were made from foam. He said they were, but he has heard that at least the blue extruded foam formula has added borax to help keep “critters” from damaging the foam when it is used on the outside of foundations. Not just sure when the formula was changed. For some reason it makes the texture of the foam just enough different, so that scribing with a pen doesn’t work as well as it used to. He did not know if the pink foam had changed formulas or not. If you have older foam, you should still be able to scribe it easily, if it doesn’t go well you probably have the new formula.
The stonework he had done looked very realistic, so I would encourage folks to give it a try for piers and walls. Scraps of the stuff are cheap, so you are out very little, except your time trying. You may have to try something a little different to scribe it. He hadn’t run out of “old” stuff, so did not know just what would work the best to scribe with.
Hope this helps,