rockislandnut,
That’s fine, but your statement was easily misinterpreted.
ALL of my comments and recommendations were directed to the OP, except for the general comment about the capacitor - as Rich explained, a VERY well known issue with both DC and DCC if you use other decoders.
Bachmann, and many other dual mode decoders run poorly or barely at all on the DC throttles I use. I use Aristo Craft Train Engineer wireless radio throttles which use pluse width modulation for motor control - just like a DCC decoder. And my own personal testing has confirmed that even with the most “conventional” of DC throttles performance is improved if the capacitors and decoder are removed.
You use DCC, good for you. If he is still listening your mechanical insights into your loco may be of value to the OP. And thank you for the pictures of a DCC version which cleared up some things.
Still the fact remains, if the OP, or anyone else plans to stay with DC, they will see much better performance from their Bachmann locos by removing the decoders, and the noise suppression capacitors - which are also present on some other brands.
Here is the problem with the capacitor. It “softens” or distorts the pulse width signals to the motor. With DC throttles like mine that means the effective starting voltage, and thereby the starting speed, is greatly increased. With DCC, using a high frequency, BEMF decoder both the effective starting voltage/speed is increased and the BEMF signal back to the decoder is distorted, causing very poor response/performance.
If you are happy with the performance of the stock Bachmann decoder, good for you, I wouldn’t suggest you change it. BUT many people do and are much happier with their Bachmann locos as a result.
Since I don’t use DCC at THIS HOUSE, my experiance on that issue is limited to the five large DCC layouts I regularly operate on, several of which I have helped build and wire. Many of those layout owners