Here’s what we’ve ended up with that seemed to work (after several other failed attempts)…
We use the little bottles of paints you buy at the arts and crafts stores… they are water based acrylics, come in hundreds of colors & shades and can cost 89 cents…
Decide if you want gray rocks, browns, reds, yellows, etc… then buy several colors/shades in that family… lights, darks, etc… and then pick up a few colors that are darker, and from another family (for example, we did gray rocks, but picked up some dark umbers and mossy greens)
Dilute the paint with water… ratio? Mess around with it, but a 50:50 or 25:75 are starting points… what you are looking for is to create a “wash” more than “paint”.
Next “splooch” it on… meaning mix up 3-5 colors, then start dabbing it all over with different colors. It may look like hell, but don’t worry (yet). BTW… start with your light colors first… then work your way to the dark colors… with washes you can darken, but can’t really lighten your work.
Let it dry, then you may want to do it again…and don’t worry about getting the same colors in the same place or hte same dilutions… you want it to look random.
When it’s good and dry, and you are somewhat satisfied, then you apply a mix of rubbing alcohol and black india ink. Again, you have to mess around with the effect. One book we read suggested 3 Tablespoons per bottle of alcohol… this pretty much made everything go black on us. We found 1-2 teaspoons per bottle worked good.
Bru***his onto your painted rocks… try to brush in one direction, either from the top to the bottom or vice versa… what you are teying to do with the india ink mix is to a) bring back the detail (three-dimensional perception) of the rocks, and to add shadows… so you want more dark on the bottoms than the top of the rocks… so brush appropriatley. Basically, the india ink which is heavier than the acohol sinks int