I have an off topic question. John Allen’s famous two stall engine house was the prototype for an FSM kit released back in the 1980s, but it was also similar in design to both the Revell and Walthers brick enginehouses in the it had one through stall and one stub end. Was this a typical arrangement for two stall enginehouses or was John Allen’s enginehouse the original source for this type of arrangement?
The “original source for this type of arrangement” is likely way back in the early 1800’s. In the prototype world. It’s kind of an obvious and convenient setup.
And, because it’s obvious and convenient (and pretty neat looking), it’s not a surprise that someone would model it.
When the Revell first came out, I did have the feeling that they copied Allen’s general layout. Doesn’t make it true,though–see second line of first paragraph.
I will say that when I decided to build my enginehouse, I did copy the layout of both. Again, see second line of first paragraph.
But one could ask: “Why did John Allen choose THIS particular arrangement?” The special and attractive part of the layout is the through track. I think usually there wasn’t one. But I haven’t made a proper survey. What’s neat is that you can extend railroad activity out the back–lots of little details and stuff. And Mr. Allen DID like setting up little scenes.
Ed
Hello! I am reviving an old thread because of two reasons.
- I just made a short video of Night time operations on my N scale layout and would love to share it so that some of you more experienced modelers could give me a little feedback and let me know what you think. (Disclaimer: I was operating at night by myself so I just put a couple of trains on cruise control while I shot the video with my smart phone. I am no professional, but I feel it gives you a good view of my working animations (crossbucks, neon signs, campfire, lighthouse beacon, flickering haunted house, arcwelder in shop, turntable, lineside and turnout signals) as well as my structure and street lighting and some custom light functions added to some of my locomotives. So please let me know what you think…
- I would love to see some photos and/or videos of other night layouts for some additional inspiration. I am really digging the night scene and love the way the layout becomes peaceful within a whole new dynamic.
I look forward to seeing what all you on this great forum have to share. Cheers!!
-John Collins
I dunno. I kinda miss Ed around here.
TF
Hi John,
If you are looking for advice I haven’t any to offer, other than to keep up the good work! Your layout looks wonderful at night! You have obviously spent a lot of time installing lighting and interiors in your buildings. The street lighting is very effective as well!
You have set a high standard for night running. I hope our club can do half as well.
Dave