Looking to hear from you all. I don’t have any experience with anything Bowser but I’m looking to expand my rolling stock of 40-50’ boxcars and see that they have some decent prices on various web sites. Is their stuff good enough for those who can’t pay $50 for a freight car? I have a mixture of Athearn, Atlas, Bachmann, Walthers, and Intermountain right now. The IM is about as much as I’m willing to pay…
Not a big Bowser owner but the stuff I own and seen has the typical molded on details, like grab irons and stirrups. I donlt think there is much underbody brake detail.
If you’re good with that kind of product then I think Bowser probably has some of the FINEST molded on details than many other producers. Some others can look pretty blocky.
They roll fine for my needs.
It is okay. Most of their stuff has cast on details, and many of their box cars are foobies. That being said, they do not make a bad model, it is just not a highly detailed one. I had a bunch of their PRR GLA hoppers, I just sold the last one, replaced by the Rapido model.
I’m not familiar with the term “foobies”, can you enlighten me?
I don’t have a lot of Bowser rolling stock but I did buy six undecorated wagon top boxcars that I lettered for my home road. They are a good quality item. As I do with all my kit built cars, I added KD couplers and wheelsets and proper weight. They are every bit as good as the Accurail cars that make up the bulk of my freight car fleet. My guess is that even if you didn’t do these upgrades, the stock wheelsets would do just fine.
Andy.
As a PRR modelers I have about 80 H21, H22 and GL hoppers, about 30 round roof boxcars in multiple versions, and around 25 cabins of the N5 and N5c variety. Along with a few FM flats and gons. I can live with cast on details as they are considered layout and transport to train show quality. Expect to replace the plastic wheels and install KDs. Some of the hoppers need the weights painted under the slope sheets. Cabins used to not have windows in the kits, but they are available and I think (not sure) they are included now.
Not too bad in my opinion.
Pete.
In this context, I’m guessing he is saying they are not prototypically accurate with their details. That’s never been a priority for me. As long as it looks realistic, that’s good enough for me.
It generally means that the railroad the car is painted for never owned that specific type of car.
If you get into the weeds of the different kinds of 50 foot boxcars for example, the model will have a specific kind of end details or door details because of the need to mass produce the car, but those details only apply to one railroad/roadnam that owned that particular kind of 50 foot boxcar. So by default, all other roadnames the model is painted with are “foobies”.
The “higehr end” models will have different tooling or different specifically applied prototypical details applied for each different roadname. Which, of course, involves more engineering and labor, so they cost more than the Bowsers. Accurails, etc.
Its a slang term for something more harsh.
I’ve always perceived this to be the most influential thing about your opinion on Bowser.
Bowser makes a lot of PRR specific things. If you’re a northeasterner, you end up with a lot of their boxes on your shelf. I’m a contemporary guy and even though their 100 ton hopper is pretty generic, they fill out a fleet quickly and in otherwise obscure road names.
A model of a prototype that never existed in real life. It could be something as simple as the wrong type of doors, the wrong number, or it could be something painted for a company that never owned that type of equipment. Some of us care about that, some people do not.
Got it. Thanks.
Yeah I’m the interim between my question and the answers that followed I put 2 and 2 together and I think I figured out what the “harsher term” is lol.
I have just one, an undecorated covered hopper I bought to deliver salt to my tanning plant. I made up the name “Salzburg Salt” and printed decals. I painted the car Reefer White, and upgraded it to Kadees and Intermountain metal wheels.
The car looks good and functions just fine.
I didn’t find any short Transition Era hoppers at the time for salt, so finding an undecorated kit for a very reasonable price made me happy.
That is what a “foobie” is.
Don’t get into the weeds. Innacurate details are just innacurate. Foobies are complete fantasy.
I model an entire FOOBIE WORLD!
[:D]
-Kevin
I’ve seen some of the more in the weeds comments suggest that if a particular car had the wrong end detail for that paint job, when the detail was correct for another roadname, then the car was a foob just because of those few details being wrong for that prototype.
Even if you’re not a PRR modeler, if you model the transition period you still need some PRR equipment. They had more of one class of boxcar than many roads had cars. The same can be said of hoppers. I have seen pictures of strings of PRR cars heading east on the UP, SP, and others. When you’re purchasing department puts in an order for 10,000 X29 boxcars, (X31 not far behind) you can bet several of them will be on every road in the northern hemisphere of the Americas.
Pete.
Some of us enjoy the “weeds”. The research to see if a car not only existed in the time period that I model, but if it would have been used in the little slice of America that I chose to model is part of the hobby, and part of the fun. To know that someone in 1965 in Ohio could have seen the exact train that I have modeled go by is satisfying.
Bowser seems to have recently transferred their manufacturing of diesels and rolling stock to China, and no longer produce them in Montoursville.
I recall going there to buy a number of model rolling stock kits, but was also allowed to buy parts from those kits, which were manufactured there, to use for upgrading older kits, produced by both Athearn and MDC.
Wayne
I meant don’t get into the weeds and use the term “foobie”. A foobie is a paint scheme on a piece of equipment that never belonged to that railroad. Like a K4 painted for the Burlington Northern.
Incorrect details are just incorrect details. Foobie is not the correct term if a model has an Ajax brake wheel and the prototype had a Miner brake wheel.
-Kevin
As I understand it Bowser has been, for some time, making the parts in their shop and then sending them to China for assembly. I have not heard that they are now doing the actual part manufacturing in China. But anything is possible.
I can’t comment on Bowsers Boxcars cos I have none.
But I got two of Bowsers RTR H30 covered hoppers and they’re great runners; straight from the box. Correct coupler heights and close to the NMRA recommended weight.
I’ve also built a number of their 70 ton 2 bay covered hopper kits; I like them!
Cheers, the Bear.[:)]