Tragedy strikes!

Today I returned to the Gulf Coast after being away doing various remote errands for the last three weeks. I went down to the layout to get it ready to operate again in the next few days. I cleaned the track and then got the 5 tray A-line tote with the engines and cars.

I wasn’t watching what I was doing and put the tray with seven locomotives too close to the edge of the layout. It went down to the concrete floor in a heartbeat. Fortunately, most of the engines were in the tray on impact, but some flew out onto the floor. If there was ever a coronary, this was it.

I looked down all these scattered engines, and like a real railroad man didn’t dwell on the accident, but immediately began to assess the damage to work out a repair and recovery plan.

First of all, several of the wheels were knocked out of the tender trucks. Once I got them back in, I put each engine on the track one by one and found that they all still worked, a miracle.

The next step was to assess the damages to details which were several. With events like this, the tiny parts will often fly into orbit and never be seen again , but it was my lucky day and I found them all. Several footboards were broken off of the locomotives, but I already have a repair plan for them. Bachmann engine steps are not very strongly attached to the locomotives, with little plastic lugs fitting into holes in the pilot and tender beams. I’m going to drill the broken lugs out of the pilot and tender beams, then make replacement lugs for the various steps out of wire which will be a lot stronger than the original attachment.

A cab roof hatch broke off, but that will be easily resecured, and one glass came out of a cab window. Naturally, it’s the one right behind the engineer and hard to access but I’ll get that back in.

In less than a minute, this terrible accident was immortalized as The Great Gulf Coast Tragedy. :joy::joy:

Anyone ever have anything like this happen? There’s no sound quite as terrible as the crash of model railroad equipment hitting the floor.

2 Likes

Oh, no! Let us know how everything turned out once you look at them.

1 Like

Yeah, one time. Damage was limited to a tender wheel and pilot a Spectrum 2-8-0.

Put it in persective. It’s only a hobby.

Executive summary-

  1. They all appear to power up, although a running test has not been executed on them. It’s possible that running gear elements were bent, but that’s fixable.

  2. All parts that broke off have been recovered. They all were attached to the locomotive by minimal cast-on plastic lugs, which snapped off in the mounting holes on the engine. Those will be drilled out with little effort, I’ve done it before. The parts will get a little piece of wire attached into a little holes drilled in the part, then inserted into the hole on the locomotive when cemented back on. The final result will be better and stronger than original, but it’s a lot better to have it not happen in the first place than go through the heartache to get it fixed.

It’s totally in perspective. A recovery plan was in place immediately.

Of course it’s only a hobby, but when you’re retired, you fill your time with it. And my pursuit in all of this is a continued connection with the wonderful times 60 years ago I had down at the railroad itself and with my layout.

2 Likes

100%. I’ve had an engine fall, but not a herd of them. I’m glad to hear they all appear fixable at this time. I hope they are. Good luck!

Very good news, the rear tender step I was most apprehensive about reconstructing is still available at the Bachmann parts store. I ordered four just in case.

The pilot that broke off of the Bachmann 63 inch driver 10 wheeler is no longer available as a separate part, but fortunately I ordered five or six a long time ago and I think I still have a couple left. This part is also found on the Russian decapod, and I’m going to urge Bachmann to restock that pilot since it’s on an engine they currently offer, and steam locomotive pilots seem to be the most frequent casualties in various accidents.

I have to say that of all the people selling plastic HO scale steam locomotives today, Bachmann stands pretty tall with parts availability. You can’t get them all, and they seem to disappear once they go out of stock but most of the time I’ve been able to get a replacement part if I needed one. You can’t say that very much about the rest of the people in the business.

Patrick, I wish that the “engines-fall” may that be the very worst event in your life here-on-in.

1 Like

Me too!

:joy::joy::joy:

The underlying message is to be extremely careful with everything.

There’s some various family activities going on right now that will go on for several days, so I won’t be able to report on progress on the engines till next week when I can finally get to them. By then I should have received my parts as well. And I will have had time to carefully consider the methodology of each repair.

None of this work is going to be particularly difficult, just time consuming

I agree–Bachmann’s part service is quite excellent. I have a N Scale F7 that was knocked down by the evil beast (in specific, Emmie the cat), and, despite being in the box, wound up with a broken pilot and truck. After talking with Bachmann, I was able to get a new truck for it with minimal complications. The silly thing still runs, somehow.

1 Like

Many years ago on my old layout, I was showing it to some cousins and running it and accidentally downloaded a caboose. Thankfully the only damage was a knocked off coupler and a displaced latter, both of which were easily repaired.

Two examples. I was a member of an early “Free-Mo style modular layout group that emphasized hand laid track, operations, and scenery. We were setting up at Dallas Fair Park and everyone was reminded not to run trains as the end protections were not in place. I was working away on my module when a brass locomotive comes roaring down the track, jumps the end of track, and hits pilot first on the concrete floor. A fall of about 52 inches. The owner of the locomotive comes running to examine the wreck. It literally bent the frame and the boiler. After a short silence, the rest of us started laughing. Our de facto leader said very loudly, :Bob, we said NO RUNNING until end protection was in place.” Bob was not happy, but he screwed up.

Fast forward a few years and I am set up with another modular group. I am working on railing a brand new Kato C44-9W on a track that extended over the end (my module was 32" wide; the other modules were 24" wide. I hit power and zoom, off the end it goes. It shattered the front coupler, the snow plaow, and one other part (can’t remember). I called Kato in Illinois; they had all parts in stock, I ordered them, and promptly put everything in a box. I recently pulled it out to install a DCC decoder, that process is still ongoing.

1 Like

I know back when I was a kid I had my layout in part of this big dining room we had at the row house we lived in at the time. This meant occasional visits from a curious cat. My mom jokingly called it “The Attack of The 50 Foot Cat.” Fortunately, all the cat really did when he got up there was bat around some of the Hot Wheels cars and army vehicles and knock over a couple El Cheapo Bachmann and Life-like cars which surprisingly I actually do still have some of over 35 years later. They don’t exactly fit my era of 1980 on up on the layout I’m currently building but I keep `em for the nostalgia and plan to run some in JFRTM ops sessions.

Oh, the chaos that comes of mixing cats and model trains.

2 Likes

Yep. Our cat found every weak spot in my layout’s wiring.




3 Likes

Oh yes, that’s how cats are!
Emmie’s one of those particularly naughty wire-chewers. I’ve lost count of how many headphones she’s ruined, and she also chewed through the wires on my Lego train, too!

Ours isn’t a wire chewer, and he’s careful about where he walks, but when following me around when I’m under the layout, he did manage to find many of the weaknesses in my old wiring set up. In a way, I should thank him since he forced me to confront the sloppy job I did when I converted from DC to DCC. Now everything is organized, tidy, secured, and labeled.

1 Like

Emmie would try to nest among the boxes that I had stored, or else among the wires (she didn’t really chew the heavier-gauge layout wires too much). Still, she has managed to skitter a number of small parts out from among hidden holes…

I also had a pet rabbit as a kid and he would chew wires as well. Interestingly he never chewed all the way through only about half way. I’m guessing maybe it irritated his teeth by the time he got halfway through or maybe he could sense current running through the other side and stopped.