Two types of couplers: Top & Bottom operation

Next is a page from the 1997 edition of Car and Locomotive Cyclopedia, showing an explanatory diagram of a type E coupler. Does anyone understand this diagram?

(1) What does “rotary operation” mean in this diagram? What is the difference between “single rotary operation” and “double rotary operation”?

(2) What does “optional” mean in “optional top operation”?

(3) Why are locomotives “top operation” and freight cars “bottom operation” used?

(4) The type H tightlock couplers on passenger train locomotives is also “top operation”, right?

Thank you for your advice.

1 Like

To point 1, the rotary operation is for any sort of car that is dumped by a rotary machine e.g. coal, gravel, woodchip, etc. The advantage is that the cars stay coupled allowing for faster emptying. Single vs double: I believe is that if the couplers are single the cars have to go all the same way in order to rotary dump. I.e. A end meets with B end. With the double, the cars can be A-end to A-end or B-end to B-end.

1 Like

While there are ‘rotary’ coupler shanks, the ‘rotary’ referred to in the drawing is about the ‘lock lift’ assembly. A single is designed for operating lever from the left side of the car and a ‘double’ will allow operation of the lock lift from either side of the car.

Rotary-shank couplers have a special anti-gravity lock which prevents unwanted uncoupling when the car is inverted 180°.

Optional top lift means that the lock lift can be supplied with an eye for top of coupler operation.

Passenger couplers are usually bottom lift arrangements because clearance is needed for a buffer plate and diaphragm.

E and F can be designed with both top or bottom locking operators. Type H and controlled slack type couplers are not designed for top-lock operation so passenger locomotives will have the bottom type.

Tightlock couplers require special carriers to allow for vertical alignment since the coupler faces will not allow for vertical movement.

Regards, Ed

5 Likes

Thank you for your detailed explanation. My long-standing question has now been answered.
Is the buffer plate (platform buffer?) mentioned in your comment also provided with the Type H?

ATSF 3759 (4-8-4) and steel caboose ATSF 999520 at the Locomotive Park in Kingman, AZ, on Feb 14, 2008

The Car and Locomotive Cyclopedia 1984 edition, ASF advertisement

4 Likes

Yes, a type H coupler and buffer plates can be used together. The buffer was an attempt to keep slack action to a minimum on passenger trains. Usually included with the diaphragm construction but you can see them on express, milk, RPO and other head end cars that sometimes don’t have diaphragms.

ACF lot #9837 005 by John W. Barriger III National Railroad Library, on Flickr

You can clearly see the buffer on this Reading baggage express car. The controlled slack coupler further helped to contain slack by taking up the inherent slop that even the type H coupler had. The controlled slack coupler had rubber pads and (I think) spring plungers in the protruding pin.

They didn’t come along until the late '40s or so.

Regards, Ed

4 Likes

You are absolutely right, Lionel’s Phaudler Milk Tank cars had working buffers.

2 Likes

Thanks for those explanations,Ed.

Rich

1 Like

Thanks to you, I was able to explain the buffer and coupler of this ATSF F7A.


The image is the cover of a book called “Complete Guide to Railroads in the Lower 48 States of America” ​​published in Japan in 2010.

1 Like

Glad to help where I can. Somebody swapped out the coupler on the 49. There should be a controlled slack tightlock in there. They probably couldn’t find one or if they did, couldn’t afford it!

Desert Rats by Bob Anderson, on Flickr

Cheers, Ed

3 Likes

Truth is stranger than fiction. Or rather, history far exceeds our imagination. Next is Union Station in Washington DC on June 9, 1993.

1 Like

The same knuckle couplers are used in my country, Japan. However, I was surprised to find that they look a little different. So I organized them in the following table. What do you think?
The reason “diaphragm” is written in thin type as “anti-slack” is because “it is said so.”

1 Like